Well, this is made to simplify the forum experience for other people, those who want to deal only with what they are interested in. This is ofc a MASSIVE change (visual and code wise), and it will take some time for me to fix some bugs, customize, and for users to get used to it. As it is now, Id say its a pain in the ass switching from one subforum to another just to check recent unread topics, but I hope im going to find a solution to that (thats my main priority atm).
Maybe it doesnt look the best now, but I believe that in a few weeks it will be much better than it is right now, making it a whole new experience. (And ofc if it turns out to be successful)
'
I concur, this is not simplifying anything. Actually it makes it more confusing for people that each part has their own forums, creating confusion regarding whether it is standalone or integrated forum.
If you wanted to extend boards for specific games, sub-boards not only would make it less confusing, but also would make them more active.
I guarantee you 99%^of these boards will end up unused.
a) because switcihing between 4 (essentially 5 if acknowledging the main forum) is too much of a hassle
b) the forum is oversatured with boards
c) the sub-forums are not visually represented well enough or intuitive enough for users to explore these sub-forums
d) Just... why?
All in all i feel like this is a bit of overthinking. There are currently not enough members to fill these boards nor is it visually, psychologically and all in all pleasing to use 4 subofrums inside of 1 forum which already is full of dead sub-boards.
EDIT/PS: Also from designer standpoint, please change the font - ideally implement a new typekit for the buttons and add a proper transition border around them. They look a bit out of place right now and the font doesn't fit the style you were going for.