I agree with Arne, proof is strictly required from normal players and admins cos otherwise people would abuse as you rightly say Ezza.
High staff are meant to be trusted members of the community, hence their position. There is an unspoken code of respect between high staff which should be followed. This means if i tell you someone did something, you should take that as truth unless i am disproven, not the other way around. If you don't trust me there's no point of me holding this position. The only reason you are so reluctant to believe and accept criticism we make of Tasha which doesn't have evidence is because of your relation to her. As i said, almost everyone in high staff discussions agreed she needed to be demoted. i made quite a clear post which gave reasons why: Bullying other players/admins. bullying in this case does not mean tasha going around swearing on ambrosia servers, it means being a constant smartass by doing things like harassing admins when she is playing under different names, pressurising them, threatening them and generally creating an uneasy playing environment. This is all bullying, and nobody is going to record this or have proof of this. proof enough should be the fact that we are all telling you this is what she does!!!
Another important thing you have to realise is that this is not simply a matter of this fight between Shark and Tasha where both were wrong. This is something which has been slowly building and growing for many months now, where she has somehow managed to turn almost everyone against her. There is no one event we have evidence of which is worthy of demoting someone. Its the culmination of events and her general attitude which has led to this situation, which is why she should not be an admin. She even admitted to flaming Cersei. That alone warrants a demote given all that has happened!
Going back to the shark incident though. Ezza maybe you have been lucky enough to always have a nice boss, but you of all people, being fairly senior here, should know that in the real world, more often than not, your boss may be a complete prick and will disrespect you, patronise you etc. If you have ANY, and i mean ANY sense at all, you would NEVER EVER behave the same way back to your boss, irrelevant of if he is wrong or right, and if you are stupid enough to do so, you have to face the music and the consequences should there be any. So crying now that "oh shark shouldn't have acted like this" is truly fruitless.
The difference between her and Altamos is Altamos flamed to people who are not in ambrosia, the only person who was pissed off by it is Tasha. Tasha flames to people in this community via steam chat, clan wars and other methods which are not officially ambrosia. If it happens once or twice or between two people who just don't get on let it slide because its not on ambrosia, but thats not the case with Tasha. she does it to everyone just for kicks. Ezza both me and you have seen and heard her rage. she goes mad all the time for the smallest things. She just can't vent her anger properly. Once again, common sense needs to be applied to situations like this.
PS. Tasha has been accusing me of not being honest and open since my last post so now i will be.
I did break rules when i played Basebuilder for about 2 weeks in August. This included shooting other bases and fixing/adjusting my base after building time and occasionally being AFK. I admit i was wrong to do this and i will happily never play on BB again or take any other punishment if one is deemed to be deserved for those actions. The biggest mistake i made though was allowing Tasha to get away with even worse offenses, including almost never attacking on BB, ghosting on jailbreak, and bullying other players/admins. Ezza both me and you know how much Tasha is constantly raging, and often expresses that by venting it on other players/admins who more often than not made an honest mistake.
At the end of the day, an admin is someone who leads by example, is honest, open, respectful and not two faced. She has none of those qualities and hence should not be an admin. If she wants to continue playing on the servers however, by all means she should.