Too me seems a hater convention or "false accusations" (copied from a member's dictionary in ambro =D)
There is clearly no need to note if the server opened yesterday or today, because there is no affection on the player(applicant) admin integration for rights. If he is so good, from past or if other people claim he was good on the previous server, you wouldn't note is because it only opened yesterday. Maturity and friendliness can be seen by saying hi to the person and interacting in different places then INGAME. I can analyze any person by talking on steam, complete scale of it's behavior, acts, past, week spots... Of course there people who are more resistant and want to go around the question (philosoph-ing more)
Other thing, Maddox you should stay on one server and that one. If u wish to change u have to risk ur first application and changing it to the other server.
Support for being a good player on almost any server in the past, without any destructive changes in the present to the bad level