No roni you're not understanding. He was perm banned, rejoined, perm banned. he was PERM banned but then rejoined. in the other cases which had a result of ban not working, they were unbanned as this was a server error (in cases from history, e.g jf)
His original perm ban was wrong that's my point. Regardless of whether or not he rejoined, smiley still PERMANENTLY banned him without him freekilling or cheating. He never got a 30 min ban is what im saying so banevading or not // still permanently banned