I agree in 100%, if you want you can unban me for just one hour and I will give you another demo..
I don't know if you got screenshot plugin on d2, but you could make some ss when I would play..
Heh, I meant not to unban, but as you were banned same day in or neighbour comunity we could watch all 4 demos. 2demos from here and 2demos from there.
So we could see how do you play from more angles. As these demos would provide us with your "suspicious gameplay" for more than 10mins.
As tbh 2nd demo waiting grmbl from b entrance isn't that doggy. I'm still sticking with my view about demo1 round2. But I'm afraid to say its a clean wh as the point that everyone uses (about 2nd demo) I can't see "fishy" as we all sometimes have guessing insta kills.
Plus that grmbl after lost round as ct always (almost) are going to camp in b behind da box! We guys are playing together for months. Sure we would learn other player behaviour!
And I'm just throwing an idea.
Also no one would unban you to see how do you play as it doesn't make a common sense.
Well although that may seem like a good way of resolving this issue and help draw a clearer picture of the whole situation, I'd have to disagree with this suggestion. This is because both communities are mutually exclusive to one another, and if you are going to punish him based on evidence that you gain from some other community, that would unfair and outside the scope of the rules and regulations of this community. As much as I want him to stay banned and never to step foot in our servers again, it would not be legitimate nor honourable to do so.
In my opinion, the demos provided by r4h is sufficient enough evidence. I understand how some people are trying to apply the standard of proof that of a criminal offence, but this however isn't a criminal court case. We have to acknowledge that things will not always be black and white and there ought to be times when some of these decisions will have to be made despite falling within the grey areas. We should NOT carry the perception that all cheaters will cheat blatantly, there are smart ones out there too. Unless some degree of strictness is imposed, they will almost be impossible to detect, and accordingly the server will never be cheat free.
Just my 2 cent.