Ok, I would like to post my opinion and please read it carefully. I will briefly explain the kills that made you guys suspicious:
First kill, from pit to A site, simply look at the dead guy and where the defendants aim is after shooting:

I would never call this kill suspicious.
Second kill, the classic "spray n pray" tactic, the guy is 30cm away so it would be unacceptable not to kill him.

Now, let's look at the spraying pattern:

Looks typical to me.
Last kill, the one in B site. Again, look at the spray:

All I can see here is the guy spraying from small distances to get kills except for that 1 kill in A site. I understand that the last kill looked a little suspicious, but it just needs better examination, the evidence is not enough to convict him. I could do better tbh, you can easily control your spray without having any no-recoil software, all it requires is some specific mouse movement, I hope I don't get banned for that too.
I find it a little disturbing that the last months we(all admins) have been seeing ghosts and banning everyone for nonsense reasons. Just look closely at the unbanned requests:

A total of 14 unbans in less than 1 month, and most of them are for wrong cheating bans. We should be more careful with bans and not just try to show we're banning people, many admins don't even seem to care about the server, just coming and banning and leaving. This is not really about Ryan or element, this is a general message. People wait days, or even weeks for a wrong ban, well, there's the reason why we're losing players, we're banning them.
For me, the evidence is not enough for this guy to be convicted.
Regards.