Ambrosia Community
Recruitment & Justice => Staff Complaints & Misconduct => Resolved Staff Complaints => Topic started by: silex™ on February 24, 2015, 11:08:25 am
-
Admin:ReFresh,Board Moderator of General-Off Topic Corner.
Server:General-Off Topic Corner.
Date & Time:24/02/2015 11:45 AM
Complaint:I started a topic in general off-topic corner with a name of "who has the best profile song"with no bad words or disrespecting terms,inside the topic i posted the link of my profile song,then ReFresh came and said"this stupid as the game",so i replied to him to him sayingif you dont like the topic don't post,he considered that i don't respect others opinions,after a while he removed the topic with no reason written or stated.
Other Evidence (screenshots, demos...):http://www.ambrosia-servers.eu/community/index.php?topic=31102.0 (http://www.ambrosia-servers.eu/community/index.php?topic=31102.0)
-
I didn't remove your topic but rather decided to archive it by providing a valid reason.
http://www.ambrosia-servers.eu/community/index.php?topic=31102.0 (http://www.ambrosia-servers.eu/community/index.php?topic=31102.0)
-
LOL.
It is just another spam topic that is non sense. Refresh is right that he removed it.
-
Its neither a spam or non sense topic, its a nice topic with a lot of sense, people like this kinda topics+the board called General Off-Topic Corner and its defenition is:Kick back, put on your slippers and have a chat!, so i dont think that my post is a spam or anything i just wanted people to show their potentials and skills in sound domain,the topic won't create any kind of disrespecting or swearing, many people posted topics that led to many probelms and they didnt get locked or removed.
-
Its neither a spam or non sense topic,its a nice topic with a lot of sense,people like this kinda topics+the board called General Off-Topic Corner and its defenition is:Kick back, put on your slippers and have a chat!,so i dont think that my post is a spam or anything i just wanted people to show their potentials and skills in sound domain,the topic won't create any kind of disrespecting or swearing,many people posted topics that led to many probelms and they didnt get locked or removed.
Yo, you know when you use a comma "," put a space after it and then continue typing since it's making your posts annoying and others find it informal. Thank you!
-
Refresh it's offtopic section
Everyone can post what they want for example your belief topic. That's sh*tload of offensive to some people yet nobody said, u hurt mi feelins :(
If you think the topic is stupid, let it die on itself. Every Time someone takes the position to tell what's stupidity finds himself in that cycle.
-
Well, it is in the general "off-topic" section and not against general rules, i don't see why it is archived, but silex, Refresh has the right to post his opinion, although it was archived very quickly .Just a PM and problem solved guys ;)
-
Its neither a spam or non sense topic,its a nice topic with a lot of sense,people like this kinda topics+the board called General Off-Topic Corner and its defenition is:Kick back, put on your slippers and have a chat!,so i dont think that my post is a spam or anything i just wanted people to show their potentials and skills in sound domain,the topic won't create any kind of disrespecting or swearing,many people posted topics that led to many probelms and they didnt get locked or removed.
The topic you started in the General Off-Topic corner was pointless and stupid. I never said that your topic was useless since most of the topics posted in that board are useless but that's not a reason to start anything you have in mind and it was not the place to start that topic since it was actually a "Forum Game" and it had to be posted in that board and that's why I questioned the point of your "Game" before taking the decision either of moving it to the "Forum Game" corner or to the Archive Board.
Even if your intention was to let people show their potentials and skills in "sound domain", your topic was still pointless. You basically wanted us to post our best profile song while nobody spends his time listening to people's profile song and by studying them. Moreover, nobody has checked all the profile songs around here so basically making a choice by just knowing 2-5 profiles is pointless. Furthermore, this is not a good way to let the show these potentials and there are actually already topics who let people post their favourite song in the music corner which people barely use.
And once again, could you stop defending yourself by providing useless information like : "my topic won't create any kind of disrespecting or swearing". Your topic has never been archived because of these reasons but because of the reasons that I'm trying to explain to you for the third time.
-
Guess it was no need for the lock even though there was some disagreement, but there were no such replies that insist the one to lock it such as insults or bad behaviour I only saw that @ReFresh didn't like the idea of it so he locked it although the topic was still fresh.
-
Its neither a spam or non sense topic,its a nice topic with a lot of sense,people like this kinda topics+the board called General Off-Topic Corner and its defenition is:Kick back, put on your slippers and have a chat!,so i dont think that my post is a spam or anything i just wanted people to show their potentials and skills in sound domain,the topic won't create any kind of disrespecting or swearing,many people posted topics that led to many probelms and they didnt get locked or removed.
The topic you started in the General Off-Topic corner was pointless and stupid. I never said that your topic was useless since most of the topics posted in that board are useless but that's not a reason to start anything you have in mind and it was not the place to start that topic since it was actually a "Forum Game" and it had to be posted in that board and that's why I questioned the point of your "Game" before taking the decision of moving it to the "Forum Game" corner or to the Archive Board.
Even if your intention was to let people show their potentials and skills in "sound domain", your topic was still pointless. You basically wanted us to post our best profile song while nobody spends his time listening to people's profile song and by studying them. Moreover, nobody has checked all the profile songs around here so basically making a choice by just knowing 2-5 profiles is pointless. Furthermore, this is not a good way to let the show these potentials and there are actually already topics who let people post their favourite song in the music corner which people barely use.
And once again, could you stop defending yourself by providing useless information like : "my topic won't create any kind of disrespecting or swearing". Your topic has never been archived because of these reasons but because of the reasons that I'm trying to explain to you for the third time.
Make yourself clear ref it is useless or not ??, the topic was about profile songs,its not a topic which should be posted in music corner coz its not about music, you posted a leaving topic right so i dont see why didn't you resign from board moderator in general off-topic corner since you said:"Ambrosia is getting boring and High Staff does not give its players the impression that they are taking care of their Community".
-
Rewrekt ^
-
Its neither a spam or non sense topic,its a nice topic with a lot of sense,people like this kinda topics+the board called General Off-Topic Corner and its defenition is:Kick back, put on your slippers and have a chat!,so i dont think that my post is a spam or anything i just wanted people to show their potentials and skills in sound domain,the topic won't create any kind of disrespecting or swearing,many people posted topics that led to many probelms and they didnt get locked or removed.
The topic you started in the General Off-Topic corner was pointless and stupid. I never said that your topic was useless since most of the topics posted in that board are useless but that's not a reason to start anything you have in mind and it was not the place to start that topic since it was actually a "Forum Game" and it had to be posted in that board and that's why I questioned the point of your "Game" before taking the decision either of moving it to the "Forum Game" corner or to the Archive Board.
Must there be a specific point in the Off-Topic section?
Sorry, I have to agree with silex and the most people here, there was no reason for it to be locked, heck there are even much worse topics that keep going with posts and I keep wondering how humanity has ended up like that. Anyway, this is not a big deal, I guess it can be resolved.
P.S. Refresh, pointless has almost the same meaning with useless, your point is invalid.
-
Make yourself clear ref it is useless or not ??, the topic was about profile songs,its not a topic which should be posted in music corner coz its not about music, you posted a leaving topic right so i dont see why you still a board moderator in general off-topic corner since you said ambrosia is geeting bored .
"Make your self clear ref it is useless or not ??" => "The topic you started in the General Off-Topic corner was pointless and stupid. I never said that your topic was useless."
"the topic was about profile songs,its not a topic which should be posted in music corner coz its not about music" => "it was actually a "Forum Game" and it had to be posted in that board and that's why I questioned the point of your "Game" before taking the decision either of moving it to the "Forum Game" corner or to the Archive Board."
"you posted a leaving topic right so i dont see why you still a board moderator in general off-topic corner since you said ambrosia is geeting bored" => That's none of your business as far as I know and I'm still on the forums and still have my moderation rights in this board if you didn't notice it so if you have nothing else to say, just don't say anything at all.
And all these who disagree with my opinion, then don't agree with it simple as that since I'm not here to please anyone but rather to do what is fair in my eyes. I didn't really have the choice since the topic was not in the right corner and had to choose either to move it to the Forum Game corner or to Trash/Archive it. If I would have moved that topic in the Forum Game corner, people would have questioned themselves about the point of the topic and that's why I decided to Archive it. As I said, I had my reasons to lock and trash this topic and if you felt butthurt too and felt like this topic should have never been locked/trashed then feel free to remove my moderation rights.
-
but refresh it is a "General Off topic" what you want to talk in off topic? only theology and atheism? it isn't against rules man,and if you see it stupid ,others no, it is your opinion, and as a mod one of your duty is to check if he is against rules or not, if not you let it, and let others who haven't the same the point of view like yours to post in.
-
He could have simply move it instead of locking it simple as that and it had nothing against the rules really.
-
You can't lock a topic if you dont like its content, you could just state your opinion, my topic was good and deserved to be posted in general off-topic and you had no righ to lock or move it, why you wrote a leaving topic and you dont want your moderation rights removed, get your mind together and decide again if you want to stay or go to another community and lock topics as you like .
-
You can't lock a topic if you dont like its content,my topic was good and deserved to be posted in general off-topic and you had no righ to lock or move it, why you wrote a leaving topic and you dont want your moderation rights removed, get your mind together and decide again if you want to stay or go to another community and lock topics as you like .
Pretty ironical coming from the one who is Admin in Ambrosia and FM in an other community.
And no, I didn't leave Ambrosia since I'm still in forums but stopped to play in the Ambrosia Jailbreak server and decided to leave my previous position for several reasons. But once again, does it bother you ?
-
about silex´s topic, maybe its pointless, but 80% of topics in these kind of sections are pointless too, so i dont find the reason for lock or archive just his topic
then u should archive almost every topic there, ur "atheist" topic included
-
Enough arguing about 1 little topic. Just move on.
-
about silex´s topic, maybe its pointless, but 80% of topics in these kind of sections are pointless too, so i dont find the reason for lock or archive just his topic
then u should archive almost every topic there, ur "atheist" topic included
He made that topic sticky like it is a necessary one, he makes unecessary topics sticky and he locks others topics and calling them stupid
-
That's the spirit gumball, use your guitar to unite refresh with silex and make a spanish algerian :D
-
How funny it is to compare that atheist topic to this one.
At least we can have an argument on the atheist one. This topic is only about getting views and posts by typing "me" or even "." on the topic.
Why waste time looking for the best profile song while you know that mine is the best one.
-
Why waste time looking for the best profile song while you know that mine is the best one.
Yours is not even a song!
-
Why waste time looking for the best profile song while you know that mine is the best one.
Yours is not even a song!
Mine for the win 8)
-
Why waste time looking for the best profile song while you know that mine is the best one.
Yours is not even a song!
It is a song. A damn good one.
It's so good that you don't recognize it's a song.
-
See you started arguing about it, thats why i made that topic so you people can share your profile songs but refresh locked and moved it to archives,you just admitted that my topic is nice.
-
Ray i checked your song>>>>you will never win that is why you are against :D :D
-
I don't find it fair at all that you archived Silex topic's and made yours the theist or atheist sticky. There is no difference between this 2 posts since both is useless but thats why its Off-Topic corner!
-
refresh dont go off topic you read the title, post and if dont like it dont,you have posted many topics which created so much probs and this is a peaceful one.
such an angry reply lol...
-
refresh dont go off topic you read the title, post and if dont like it dont,you have posted many topics which created so much probs and this is a peaceful one.
such an angry reply lol...
You know why i said that ?, coz he said thats really stupid, he thinks that he is the only who has the best topics.
-
Are you kidding me or what?
If you want to start your topic, do it but don't do it in the Off-Topic corner but rather in the Forum Game corner and stop arguing about some random sh!t because if I made that topic sticky it was because I felt like it had to be sticky since it is a place in which people can share their beliefs and I believe that it's one of these topics that should be kept active in time. If the topic manages to become inactive then somebody from the staff or me (if I'm still moderator in the Off-Topic corner at that time) will make it non-sticky and will probably archive it. That has nothing to do about your opinion which says that I might think that I'm the one who makes the best topics because that's false since most of my topics are spam or pointless and I'm myself aware of that but that topic was an exception and I believe that this topic is more important than the topic "share your pets" that is currently sticky (was stickied by Koray) and that you didn't even bother to take as an example because we can perfectly see that the purpose of your posts are not to try to understand the reason of the archival of your thread that I might now consider as a bit illogical and I believe that I should have moved your topic to the Forum Game corner instead so it would have not been my matter anymore like PL told me in the shoutbox but I can perfectly see that your intention is to get my moderation rights stripped since you talked about my leaving and about other things I have done as a moderator of that board.
-
such an angry reply lol...
Oh you're saying that was an angry reply that's why ReFresh locked that topic? show me the offensive side of it then.
-
locked.
-
From my perspective i would have left the topic open but perhaps moved to a more relevant section. Anyway, the topic did seem a bit errrr on the dull side :D
RESOLVED
-
From my perspective i would have left the topic open but perhaps moved to a more relevant section. Anyway, the topic did seem a bit errrr on the dull side :D
RESOLVED
Aaaah comon
Am i really the only one that did not think this topic was going anywhere at all?
It really seemd so pointless